Arthur Morgan Vs John Marston Who Would Win
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1661b/1661b7d5fdf1e73eabc6d3d0191aa7c35da9b246" alt="Red Dead Redemption 2 A Complete Guide Of Arthur Morgan"
Arthur takes the fistfight john takes the rest.
Arthur morgan vs john marston who would win. Warning spoilers for red dead redemption 1 2. If this is any kind of melee fight arthur wins pretty easily. Arthur is older and so has survived more fights aka more experience so he might stand a better chance of winning round 2. Arthur appears to be stronger and tougher so he easily takes the fistfight.
Most of these rounds have john marston from rdr1. They both decide to have a duel. The only realistic thing you could say is they are both outlaws so definitely use to killing people and john is i believe 10 years younger so he might have a slight advantage with the draw. By the end of the game i am sure that arthur will be regarded as the better lead because we as gamers will have developed his character and put more of ourself into him.
He has much more experience in h2h combat and this shows not only in fight animations but in lore. All rounds take place in the town of armadillo and they can take cover. They only have standard revolvers and nothing else. As a lead character in a story i think that marston wins but as a lead in a game it probably works out more in arthurs favour.
John was shown to have more impressive riding abilites then arthur still its fairly close. John shows some decent ability and skill but arthur is much bigger tougher and arguably more skilled. Arthur is not just the trigger man he is the muscle of the van der linde gang. Who would win john marston vs arthur morgan.
P s please come back to this post when dlc for rdr2 is out so you can debate further. They both have their complet weapons wheels.