Arthur Morgan Or John Marston Poll
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1cac6/1cac6b330657ac15962e1c81688065a19037cb58" alt="Days Gone Update 1 51 What S New And What Are Patch Notes Film"
Arthur morgan is a better protagonist than john marston.
Arthur morgan or john marston poll. They re both great but john has a voice like rough honey whiskey and that trumps all. Big spoiler in this post so don t continue unless you ve beaten the game. Arthur morgan or john marston. Arthur morgan for sure.
I m pretty bothered by the ending of rdr2. I think that many people who will take part in this poll haven t played the first game unfortunately. Even john as a side char has more personality in this game than his own. My take and kind of a video essay on who i believe the better protagonist is arthur morgan of the prequel red dead redemption 2 or john marston of the first red dead redemption.
If you combine both games john is better imo. Well i still can t figure out which is arthur morgan during parts of the game that they talk. It s a question that we ve been asking ourselves ever since we finished red dead redemption 2 obviously the recently released sequel is going to be much more fresh. Arthur morgan is a horrible protagonist so of course john marston is the winner.
I loved every minute of playing as him. Arthur morgan vs john marston. John is very reluctant to leave arthur behind before he dies and is deeply saddened by his death posthumously referring to him as an old friend and using arthur s ring to marry abigail. A subreddit for rockstar s critically acclaimed open world western game red dead redemption its prequel red dead redemption 2 and its online multiplayer red dead online.
A few weeks ago i dedicated a fair amount of words to talking about why the original red dead redemption s protagonist john marston is to put it plainly so damn good. Arthur morgan or john marston. Obviously the recently released sequel is going to be much more fresh in most people s minds including our own but we can t ignore how much we liked playing as john marston in the original red dead.